I have used cheap firewire cases for many, many years on all of my
computers, buying bare internal IDE CD and, later, DVD drives. I have
never had any problem except early on with Double layer when I got a
lot of burned DVDs that did not play properly, usually screwing up at
the layer transfer point. But that was all with Memorex DL writable
discs, and once I switched brands I never had any trouble again.
One thing I should say about the cheap enclosures: I have used dozens
of them for hard drives also, and now and then a bridge board fails. So
while it's statistically very unlikely to have one fail, ever, under
light use, under continuous use I'd estimate a 10% chance of a board
failure every 2-3 years.
>> Stay informed about: External enclosure for DVD burner: fan important? TDK OK? ..